Rockford Top Rated

Pizza

Top Rated Pizza in the Rockford Area

Ranked by Google rating, adjusted for how many reviews that rating is based on, so a perfect score from a handful of reviews cannot outrank a strong score from hundreds. Payment does not affect this list. Full method.

Ratings retrieved from Google on September 18, 2026.

The Top 5

Ranked by rating, adjusted for review volume.

  3. No. 3

    John's Restaurant & Pizzeria

    • Rockford
    • Locally owned

    4.6

    1204 reviews

    out of 5 on Google

    (815) 398-4044 About Us John's Pizza Restaurant and Pizzeria is a family-owned and operated restaurant that has been in business for over 50 years.

    CallWebsite

  4. Buona

    • Loves Park

    4.6

    634 reviews

    out of 5 on Google

    Buona is a fast-food restaurant in Loves Park, IL. Serving Italian beef, Chicago-style hot dogs, burgers, chicken, salads, and more. Order Online.

    CallWebsite

  5. Maciano's Pizza & Pastaria

    • Rockford

    4.5

    2267 reviews

    out of 5 on Google

    Maciano's Rockford offers daily promotions & catering on homemade Italian food, pizza, pasta for casual dining, carryout and fast delivery

    CallWebsite

Also Highly Rated

Positions 6 to 10.

  5. Sam's Ristorante & Pizzeria

    • Rockford

    4.4

    1506 reviews

    out of 5 on Google

    Order Online gino@samsristorante.com Purchase Gift Cards Online A Rockford Tradition for Dining & Celebrations Since 1974 Italian favorites, full-service…

    CallWebsite

New & Notable

Rated 4.5 or higher with fewer than 15 reviews. Newer businesses worth knowing about.

Own one of these businesses?

Take the featured spot at the top of this page, or send us a correction to your listing. Both start with an email.

See placement ratesUpdate a listing