Highest rated
Dairyhaus
- Rockton
4.8
1055 reviews
out of 5 on GoogleIce Cream & Dessert
Top Rated Ice Cream in the Rockford Area
Ranked by Google rating, adjusted for how many reviews that rating is based on, so a perfect score from a handful of reviews cannot outrank a strong score from hundreds. Payment does not affect this list. Full method.
Ratings retrieved from Google on September 18, 2026.
The Top 5
Ranked by rating, adjusted for review volume.
- No. 2
Cattle & Cream
- Cherry Valley
4.8
602 reviews
out of 5 on GoogleLearn More About Cattle & Cream: We carry only Choice USDA Black Angus Beef or higher.
- No. 3
The Scoop
- Winnebago
4.9
98 reviews
out of 5 on Google DIYogurt
- Belvidere
4.9
68 reviews
out of 5 on GoogleCreate your own frozen yogurt or gelato at D.I.Yogurt! Choose flavors & toppings for a custom treat. Visit us today!
Choices Natural Market
- Loves Park
4.7
345 reviews
out of 5 on GoogleAt Choices Natural Market, we’ve already done the work—reading labels and selecting products we trust—so you can feel confident in what you buy.
Also Highly Rated
Positions 6 to 10.
Buddy's Burgers
- Rockford
4.6
1349 reviews
out of 5 on GooglePick from our list of toppings to create your own personal burger!...
La Michoacana Mexican Creamery - Loves Park
- Loves Park
4.7
202 reviews
out of 5 on Google--> Ice Cream Shop | La Michoacana Mexican Creamery | Loves Park top of page ORDER ONLINE HOME OUR MENU OUR FLAVORS ABOUT US EMPLOYMENT CONTACT More Use…
Sebastian’s Cafe
- Roscoe
4.7
194 reviews
out of 5 on GoogleSebastian’s Café is where small-town charm meets big flavor — a cozy Roscoe favorite serving comfort classics, fresh coffee, and warm smiles in every vis…
Candy Cloud - Rockford
- Rockford
4.6
751 reviews
out of 5 on GoogleSelect Your Favourites From Our Wide Range Of Specialty Drinks, Coffee, and Creamery. Order Online Or In Store.
M & M Dari Ripple
- South Beloit
4.6
685 reviews
out of 5 on Google
New & Notable
Rated 4.5 or higher with fewer than 15 reviews. Newer businesses worth knowing about.
Las Guacamayas
- Belvidere
4.5
6 reviews
out of 5 on GoogleGelato Joe's
- Loves Park
5.0
4 reviews
out of 5 on GoogleWe make classic gelato flavors like chocolate, vanilla and pistachio and we also feature a broad range of more adventurous gelato and sorbet flavors such…
Own one of these businesses?
Take the featured spot at the top of this page, or send us a correction to your listing. Both start with an email.