Rockford Top Rated

Ice Cream & Dessert

Top Rated Ice Cream in the Rockford Area

Ranked by Google rating, adjusted for how many reviews that rating is based on, so a perfect score from a handful of reviews cannot outrank a strong score from hundreds. Payment does not affect this list. Full method.

Ratings retrieved from Google on September 18, 2026.

Filter47 of 47

The Top 5

Ranked by rating, adjusted for review volume.

  2. Cattle & Cream

    Cherry Valley

    4.8602 Google reviewsout of 5

    Learn More About Cattle & Cream: We carry only Choice USDA Black Angus Beef or higher.

    CallWebsite

  4. DIYogurt

    Belvidere

    4.968 Google reviewsout of 5

    Create your own frozen yogurt or gelato at D.I.Yogurt! Choose flavors & toppings for a custom treat. Visit us today!

    CallWebsite

  5. Choices Natural Market

    Loves Park

    4.7345 Google reviewsout of 5

    At Choices Natural Market, we’ve already done the work, reading labels and selecting products we trust, so you can feel confident in what you buy.

    CallWebsite

Every other ice cream & dessert we rank

Positions 6 to 47, same method.

  1. Buddy's Burgers

    Rockford

    4.6Call

  2. La Michoacana Mexican Creamery - Loves Park

    Loves Park

    4.7Call

  3. Sebastian’s Cafe

    Roscoe

    4.7Call

  4. Candy Cloud - Rockford

    Rockford

    4.6Call

  5. M & M Dari Ripple

    South Beloit

    4.6Call

  6. Dairy Depot

    Loves Park

    4.6

  7. Benny's Dariette

    Rockford

    4.6Call

  8. La Michoacana Denisse

    Rockford

    4.7Call

  9. La Michoacana Cafè

    Poplar Grove

    4.9Call

  10. Doc's Diner

    Loves Park

    4.5Call

  11. La Michoacana Tropical Oasis

    South Beloit

    4.6Call

  12. Willyums Dari Fair

    Rockford

    4.5Call

  13. Sweets N' Eats

    Rockford

    4.5Call

  14. Zammuto's Drive-In & Carry-Out

    Rockford

    4.5Call

  15. Cooper's Corner Ice Cream

    Rockford

    4.9Call

  16. Culver’s

    Roscoe

    4.4Call

  17. Halo Bakeshop

    Loves Park

    4.6Call

  18. La Michoacana Belvidere

    Belvidere

    5.0Call

  19. Waffle Shop Family Restaurant

    Loves Park

    4.4Call

  20. Yumberry Frozen Yogurt

    Rockford

    4.5Call

  21. Rock Cut State Park Concession

    Loves Park

    4.4Call

  22. Dari Ripple

    Belvidere

    4.4Call

  23. Cool zone michoacana

    Rockford

    4.8Call

  24. Wicked Sweets by Kate

    Rockton

    4.9Call

  25. Sugarjones

    Loves Park

    4.4Call

  26. Culver’s

    Rockford

    4.3Call

  27. La Michoacana Mexican Creamery- On Kishwaukee

    Rockford

    4.4Call

  28. Cold Stone Creamery

    Rockford

    4.3Call

  29. Baskin-Robbins

    Rockford

    4.3Call

  30. La Michoacana- On Broadway

    Rockford

    4.3Call

  31. Quenchers Smoothies

    Rockford

    4.4Call

  32. Lone Rock Cafe

    Loves Park

    4.5Call

  33. Dairy Queen Grill & Chill

    Rockford

    4.0Call

  34. Potbelly

    Machesney Park

    4.1Call

  35. La Michoacana Flor De Mexico

    Belvidere

    4.0Call

  36. Helados la michoacana

    Rockford

    4.7Call

  37. Yumberry

    Machesney Park

    4.0Call

  38. Dairy Queen Grill & Chill

    Loves Park

    3.7Call

  39. Sonic Drive-In

    Loves Park

    3.5Call

  40. Dairy Queen Grill & Chill

    Roscoe

    3.4Call

  41. The Original Rainbow Cone

    Loves Park

    3.8Call

  42. Bucciferro Family McDonald's

    Roscoe

    3.0Call

New & Notable

Rated 4.5 or higher with fewer than 15 reviews. Newer businesses worth knowing about.

  2. Gelato Joe's

    Loves Park

    5.04 Google reviewsout of 5

    We make classic gelato flavors like chocolate, vanilla and pistachio and we also feature a broad range of more adventurous gelato and sorbet flavors such as coffee crunch, orange dreamsicle and lemon basil sorbet.

    CallWebsite

Own one of these businesses?

Take the featured spot at the top of this page, or send us a correction to your listing. Both start with an email.

See placement ratesUpdate a listing